One of the biggest obstacles in homeschooling today, is the snare that every parent finds themselves in at one time or the other: The Comparison Trap.
By definition, homeschooling consists of parents and guardians who have chosen to be more involved in their ward’s education. By choosing homeschooling as an alternative, the parent is making an active choice to better their child’s academic upbringing. With this level of dedication, it’s perfectly natural to not only want the best for our child but also desire to have all the tools and knowledge necessary for success.
No sane person chooses homeschooling for it to fail. The choice to homeschool is followed up by the desire to do our best and enhance our child’s education. Anything regarding homeschooling, whether it's a statistical report or a social media post, will get us comparing our homeschooling attributes to theirs.
Questions we often ask ourselves:
These insecurities can not only frustrate us but ultimately start hampering our homeschooling skills. There might come a point that we start turning into a liability instead of our child's greatest asset.
In the homeschooling world, playing “Keeping up with the homeschooled Jonese’s” is a categorical mistake, and can have catastrophic outcomes.
As humans, we use comparisons from the time we are barely toddlers. Most of our life decisions are directly or indirectly rooted in comparisons. Our choice of spouse, the house we live in, employment, cars, pets, vacation spots, even the movies we choose can be linked to mental comparisons that the mind computes sub consciously.
No, not at all. Upward comparisons to a large group or data on a well researched topic may prove to be useful, if used to move ourselves in the right direction. However, this is tricky to maintain with a positive bend as comparisons can and will lead to self doubt, dissatisfaction and low self esteem.
Generally homeschooling comparison falls into two broad categories:
This broadly covers judging our skills as the primary educator, as either inadequate, lacking resources, missing key points, or other factors. Self comparison generally stems from when we are presented with someone else's homeschooling methodology.
When faced with another child’s progress, the feeling that our child could do better, or that our child lacks the necessary skills can transform to self-blame, surreal expectations, and result in disappointments.
Comparison as a prelude to motivate progress is not necessarily a bad thing. Self doubt can lead to better and improved versions of ourselves. It’s the journey we embark on after comparing, that often leads us astray.
We often forget to remind ourselves that every child is different. Learning and progressing are not simplistic checkpoints, but often arbitrary constraints. There are many reasons that we compare what we perceive to be a disparity in learning.
We all secretly want to be that parent whose child wins awards and wins first place. Realistically, we can easily accept the fact that there’s a good chance it won’t happen. However, when we find out that someone else's child is way ahead in the planned curriculum, or has completed reading a book that our child hasn’t even started, it’s irksome! Some parents feel that another child in their homeschooling group is on advanced calculus, while theirs is still struggling with basic algebra. Fear creeps in, and we start questioning ourselves. Are we doing our best? And can we do more?
Let’s stop and ask ourselves one question. Why did we decide to homeschool? Wasn’t it to solve issues like the above? If our child was going to school right now, chances are when faced with the same issues, the school won’t have the time to fix the problem. But we can!
If our child is slow at Math, we can tailor a course that suits his pace or get additional help to rectify it. If the other kid is faster at reading, good for them. Our child doesn’t need to keep up with them. That's the
beauty of
homeschooling. It can be done at a pace that we and more importantly our child is comfortable with.
We know that comparisons happen when we think either we or our children are far below the normal. As rational adults, we must understand that “normal” is not a fixed point to be achieved. Normal is a changing spectrum that each child defines for themselves. We need to recognize the “normal” for our child.
The two other external comparisons that can really infiltrate our peace of mind and make us question our ability to home educate are:
On social media, we come across the perfect homeroom settings, with matching furniture and spacious dedicated areas, or at a fellow homeschooler’s house. These images can be triggering, because we want the best for our children and think that they would do so much better in a setting like the one we just saw.
Let’s instead ask ourselves, “Is our child learning?” That should be much more important than aesthetics. We can always get tips online to
set up our home and maximise the space by buying or building storage objects that best fit our allocated rooms.
2. Why do other people have better resources?
With education fast becoming high tech, there are new softwares, education packs, interactive gadgets, learning tablets and so much more that helps homeschooling. We all know someone who has something new and better, and for our child’s benefit, we feel that we should get it too if it can help them succeed.
However, the more important question to ask ourselves should be “Are the tools I have, doing the job as far as my child is concerned?” If the answer is yes, then we really don’t need the upgrade. It's really that simple.
The best comparison for our children would be with themselves. By gauging our child’s abilities from a few months back to now, we will see their level of progression. We can then set up more achievable goals.
It’s important to celebrate each milestone they achieve, or change the criteria or methods and start afresh if they haven't.
To help you on your journey through home education, Summa Summarum Education offers a variety of resources and aids for home educators, as well as home education consultancy. Feel free to reach out to us at any time.
Summa Summarum Education
Thank you for signing up to the Summa Summarum Education newsletter. You will be the first to know about event dates, free weekly lessons and new blog posts!
Uh oh, that didn't work! Please try again or alternatively send me an email with the subject "Newsletter signup".